Previous | Read this before cashing out your retirement account due to COVID-19 Next | Unsecured or secured loans: What's best for you?
August 17, 2020 / The Merrill Anderson Company
A GRAT in action

A GRAT in action

The Grantor-Retained Annuity Trust (GRAT) has emerged as a popular strategy in the estate planner’s toolkit. The idea is that a grantor places assets in a trust while retaining the right to receive payments from the trust. When the term of the trust expires, any assets remaining in the trust pass to a beneficiary, typically a family member.

Here’s an example of a GRAT that, unfortunately, failed. On February 1, 1998, Patricia Yoder created a Grantor-Retained Annuity Trust, keeping for herself a fixed annuity for 15 years. The annuity was set at 12.5 percent of the trust’s initial value. The trust was funded with investment real estate, and the annuity came to $302,259 per year. Although the value of the trust’s income varied from year to year, the annuity payments to Patricia did not change, and they were timely paid.
man holding money next to shield with lock icon
Patricia died November 2, 2012, three months shy of the expiration of the GRAT’s term. Her estate tax return reported a total taxable value of $36.8 million, including the value of the GRAT. Some $11.1 million in estate taxes were paid. Someone then had second thoughts and believed that including the GRAT in the taxable estate was a mistake. A refund of $3.8 million was sought, and when the IRS did not respond, the matter went to District Court.

The estate argued that a fixed annuity is not a “right to income” within the meaning of the tax code section that covers this area. An annuity is the right to receive payments from transferred property, regardless of the income earned by the property. The Court acknowledged that there is no case directly on point, but using a substance-over-form reasoning held that the estate tax does apply in this situation. The U.S. Supreme Court has held that the grantor's reservation of any interest, however remote, was sufficient to bring the conveyance within the code's "possession or enjoyment" language of the tax code.

With that much money at stake, an appeal was filed with the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. That Court has now affirmed the District Court decision.

Had Patricia chosen a 14-year trust term, or if she had lived just three more months, the $3.8 million tax would have been avoided.

(June 2020)
© 2020 M.A. Co. All rights reserved.
Recent Articles
An introduction to 401(k) plans
An introduction to 401(k) plans

An introduction to 401(k) plans

December 27, 2021 / F&M Trust

Five things you can do to get out of debt
Five things you can do to get out of debt

Five things you can do to get out of debt

December 17, 2021 / F&M Trust

How to create an emergency fund (before the emergency)
How to create an emergency fund (before the emergency)

How to create an emergency fund (before the emergency)

December 10, 2021 / F&M Trust

How to protect your identity and spot signs of fraud
How to protect your identity and spot signs of fraud

How to protect your identity and spot signs of fraud

December 06, 2021 / F&M Trust

Tax Law Changes: The American Families Plan and how it might impact you
Tax Law Changes: The American Families Plan and how it might impact you

Tax Law Changes: The American Families Plan and how it might impact you

October 14, 2021 / Erin Sunday

Tax Law Changes: A closer look at estate and gift taxes
Tax Law Changes: A closer look at estate and gift taxes

Tax Law Changes: A closer look at estate and gift taxes

October 12, 2021 / Erin Sunday

Tax Law Changes: A closer look at corporate taxes
Tax Law Changes: A closer look at corporate taxes

Tax Law Changes: A closer look at corporate taxes

October 07, 2021 / Erin Sunday

Tax Law Changes: A closer look at individual taxes and what the changes mean for you
Tax Law Changes: A closer look at individual taxes and what the changes mean for you

Tax Law Changes: A closer look at individual taxes and what the changes mean for you

October 05, 2021 / Erin Sunday

Why keeping up with the Joneses is never a good idea
Why keeping up with the Joneses is never a good idea

Why keeping up with the Joneses is never a good idea

September 30, 2021 / F&M Trust

Join our e-newsletter

Sign up for our e-newsletter to get new content each month.

NOTICE: YOU ARE LEAVING F&M TRUST!

You are now leaving the F&M Trust website. Links to third-party sites are provided for your convenience. Such sites are not within our control and may not follow the same privacy, security or accessibility standards as ours. F&M Trust neither endorses nor guarantees offerings of the third-party providers, nor is F&M Trust responsible for the security, content or availability of third-party sites, their partners or advertisers.